19 June
2005 Editorial by Peter J. Carr, Chatmag Publisher.
For years, Yahoo!
chat has been most casual Internet user's introduction to online discussions.
Yahoo! operates a very user friendly chat interface, with minimal software
requirements. All a user needs is a Java enabled web browser to use Yahoo!
chat. No other software, such as is required for IRC (Internet Relay Chat)
is necessary.
I started chatting
on Prodigy in 1996, and when Yahoo! first offered chat, I moved there,
and have been an active member of the chat community ever since. It was
a great place to meet people from around the world, and form friendships
that last to this day.
Many Internet
users formed friendships on Yahoo! chat, and a lot of groups migrated to
chat, rather than the separate Yahoo! Groups. Teenagers are the largest
single group using chat and IM, and this now leaves them little choice
than to transfer to other IM/chat services.
At first, Yahoo!
chat had no advertisements, and the obnoxious "ad bots" were still a few
years away. Only in recent years has the look and feel of Yahoo!
chat changed, for the worse. And, more and more "ad bots" have taken over,
making for a frustrating chat environment.
Yahoo! had knowledge
of both the "ad bots" and the pedophile chat rooms. Not only Chatmag, but
many other users complained, including several that formed petitions requesting
chat moderators. All of which Yahoo! chose to ignore.
The problem is
not the advertisements, but how they are implemented on Yahoo! A user logs
in using the IM client, and choses "Chat" from the tool buttons. An advertisement
page loads, and is timed for up to one minute, before the "Enter Chat"
button is activated. Yahoo! obviously does not "target" any specific
chat, the advertisement can be seen prior to entering any Yahoo! chat room.
In contrast, Chatmag's
Directory tightly target's advertisers by topics, and we also preview each
listing to ensure that the chat room or discussion forum meets our
criteria of being a safe, on topic site. Any potential listing not meeting
Chatmag's standards are excluded from inclusion into the Directory.
Yahoo! can still
be a good chat environment, if Yahoo! implements chat moderators, and proactively
deletes chat rooms of a questionable nature, most specifically, any pedophile
related or hate group chat rooms.
The advertisers
that pulled their ads should be given assurances by Yahoo! that changes
have been made, and their advertisements will be shown in a more favorable
chat environment.
Internet chat
will suffer little due to the current problems at Yahoo! There are numerous
chat sites, and as long as people want to communicate, chat will be an
active part of the Internet experience.