Update
10 January 2005 ABC News Original Report.
Controversial
Web Site Claims to 'Out' Would-Be Child Molesters
Protecting
Kids or Perverting Justice?
Update 29 December
2004
Perverted Justice
Target of FBI Investigation.
Bradley Russ,
Director of training for the Internet Crimes Against Children Task Force,
in a statement regarding Perverted Justice's tactics said in an interview
with Geoffrey Gray, Staff Reporter on the New York Sun, "Perverted Justice's
"aggressive" tactics often go against national standards. By accepting
child pornography online from pedophiles to make a better case, the training
director, Bradley Russ, said, the contributors at Perverted Justice were
themselves possessing unlawful contraband, and federal authorities are
now considering whether or not to seize their computers."
Cyberangels,
an offshoot of The Guardian Angels, created by Curtis
Sliwa (yes, he uses his real name), has a section regarding online
child pornography. According to the Cyberangels web site regarding what
is child pronography:
"Child pornography
can also be simple text that describes sexual acts or is intended to provide
sexual gratification."
Perverted Justice
operators place photographs on the profiles used in their "busts". These
photographs depict underage girls, and are usually taken from various sources
available on the Internet. By using these photographs, they violate
Federal Obscenity laws regarding child pornography. Perverted Justice
maintains they are above the law, and able to conduct their "busts" in
any manner they choose. This above the law attitude will be their downfall.
Update 23 December
2004
Wikipedia Censored
by Eide.
Phillip Eide,
owner of Perverted Justice has in recent days edited out certain portions
of the Wikipedia
article regarding his site. The Wikipedia is a user-edited encyclopedia,
with a "neutral point of view" stance regarding posts. Eide has over the
past few days deleted mention of this article, and other information contrary
to Perverted Justice. Repeated
messages to Eide by several editors of the Wikipedia to maintain the
"NPOV" have been disregarded.
In another posting
his statement regarding anyone questioning Perverted Justice: "Some
critics have expressed concern or opposition in regard to Perverted-Justice.com,
with the administration of the web sites illustrating that most critics
are outside the United States, and labeling them as defenders of pedophiles."
This censorship
of opposing viewpoints is contrary to the spirit of Wikipedia, and only
furthers the belief that Perverted Justice is not to be regarded as a serious
deterrent to online predators. This also raises the question as to whether
any of the chat logs on Perverted Justice can be trusted as authentic.
Censoring Wikipedia demonstrates that Eide is capable of editing chat logs.
News Articles:
Perverted
Justice aids in return of 14 year old girl.
Internet
Sleuth Finds Kidnapped Teen.
News Article:
Class
Action Lawsuit being filed against Perverted Justice.
News Article:
Perverted
Justice not wanted in Canada.
News Article:
Perverted
Justice declared a "cult".